Synopsis: Even though routers and shapers perform the same basic functions, there are critical differences. In this article, professional furniture maker J. Speetjens demonstrates why he has both tools in his shop. A few of his arguments? Shapers make heavier cuts, can handle large runs of moldings, and can cut larger profiles than a router. They have a sliding table and a reversible motor, which lets you do template work without worrying about cutting against the grain. The ability to flip some cutters adds to the shaper’s flexibility.

Stripped to their essentials, a router mounted in a router table and a shaper are the same—a machine with a vertical, motorized spindle holding cutters to mill wood. As a professional woodworker, I consider both router and shaper indispensable. Sometimes, I choose one machine over the other simply because of the cutters I have available. But often only one of the machines can handle the task at hand. Even though routers and shapers perform the same basic functions, there are some critical differences.

Routers have taken over the hobbyist market, largely because of cost and partly because shapers have a reputation for being dangerous. An antiquated cutterhead system was notorious for firing shaper knives across shops at ballistic speeds. But these cutters, commonly termed slick-back knives, have been replaced by better, safer designs. In my experience, shapers are no more or less dangerous than jointers, planers, routers, or even drill presses.

If you’re setting up a new shop or upgrading the machines you already have, you may want to consider adding a shaper to expand the range of profiles you can create. In general, a shaper can make heavier cuts, and can make them much cleaner. A shaper easily handles large runs of moldings, cutting larger profiles than a router as well as a wider range of curves. I’ll even use the shaper for small moldings if I want a profile I can’t get from router bits. A shaper’s miter slot or sliding table makes it easier to cut tenons and cope-and-stick joints. And if your shaper has a reversible motor, you can do template work without worrying about cutting against the grain; the ability to flip some cutters adds to the shaper’s flexibility.

Size and heft make for smooth cuts

A shaper rated at 3 hp is a much more substantial machine than a 3-hp router. Routers hold their bits with a collet and nut attached to the motor shaft. Shapers are designed so that cutters, bearings, spacers, and guards slip directly onto the motor shaft, held fast with a nut on the top. Where the router has a 1⁄2-in. collet, the shaper has a 3⁄4-in. or 1-in.-dia. shaft. The drawing on p. 87 highlights the features that give a shaper its muscle.

From Fine Woodworking #195

For the full article, download the PDF below:

Fine Woodworking Recommended Products

Shop Fox W1826

The thick, felted bag on this Shop Fox is a plus and a minus. On one hand, it makes the unit much less expensive than collectors with canister filters, and also lighter and easier to hang on the wall. Without a separate plastic bag to catch chips, however, they stay in the felt bag, and the shortish zipper on the bottom makes it tough to shake them out. Otherwise, the W1826 is an excellent value.

Buy at Amazon

Rockler Dust Right 650 CFM

While all five of the smaller units will collect chips efficiently when deployed properly, the 3/4-hp Rockler was just a bit more powerful in our suction test.

Buy at Amazon

Starrett 12-in. combination square

This accurate, robust, well-machined, easy-to-read combo square is as great as ever.

Buy at Amazon