A Forstner bit is the best way to bore high-quality holes that are accurately sized, accurately located, and with a cleanly cut rim. Today, the bits come in a variety of designs. To find out which ones are best, I tested 18 brands judging them by several criteria: Size, chip-clearing, temperature, and drilling ability.

Size –  I tested 1/2-in.-dia. and 1-in.-dia. bits. I measured the diameter of each bit to see how close it was to the specified size, and then I measured the diameter of the hole itself. Most holes were slightly larger than the bit that drilled them, indicating slight runout. For the Fisch bits, the 1/2-in.-dia. bit was 0.499-in.-dia.and the 1-in.-dia. bit was 1.001-in.-dia. The bits drilled holes that were 0.507-in.-dia. and 1.003-in.-dia. respectively.

Chip Clearing – Bits choked with chips don’t cut well and may increase friction and burning. Many of the 1/2-in.-dia. bits, including the one from Fisch, became badly plugged when the head went below the wood’s surface. Fisch’s 1-in.-dia bit, however, cleared chips.

Temperature – To test the longevity of the bits, I mounted each 1-in.-dia. bit in a drill press. I chose the larger bits for this test because there is a greater area in contact with the wood, and therefore more friction. I set the speed to 480 rpm and drilled 100 holes 1 in. deep in hickory, a wood known for its ability to dull a sharp cutter. I used a digital infrared thermometer to check each bit’s temperature every 10 bores. An increase in temperature could signal a dulling cutting edge. While the temperatures ranged from 134ºF to 268ºF, the Fisch bit measured an average of 165°F. In general, bits that made cleaner cuts generated less heat.

Drilling Ability – No other type of bit can match the quality of a Forstner for the cut around the rim and sides of a hole. The Fisch 1/2-in.-dia. bit left a bore rim with very good quality, while the 1-in. bit was of excellent quality.

I also tested to see how the 1/2-in. bit cut overlapping holes and holes drilled at an angle. The rim design in Forstner bits allow you to drill clean overlapping holes, as when excavating a mortise. The 1/2-in-dia. Fisch bit scored a “very good” in its ability to bore overlapping holes, while the 1-in.dia bit received excellent results in the test.

The Forstner bit’s sharp rim also makes it easy to start the bit in a steeply angled workpiece, as when cutting pocket holes in a table apron. The Fisch bits received a “very good” score when tested for this.

Overall, I picked Famag bits as the best overall in the tests. Grizzly gets the nod for best value.
 
The Fisch bits are available from amazon.com.

Fine Woodworking Recommended Products

Festool Cleantec CT 26 E HEPA Dust Extractor

The clear winner here is Festool’s CT 48 Dust Extractor. It has amazing capacity relative to its size, and unmatched suction power. It packs in a number of subtle but very helpful design touches, like a clever foot brake and easy hose and cord storage.

Buy at Amazon

Ridgid EB4424 Oscillating Spindle/Belt Sander

With five spindles sized from 1/2 in. to 2 in. and a 4 X 24-in. belt, this sander has become a staple in many a shop Fine Woodworking visits.

Buy at Amazon

Bosch 12V Trim Router

Trim routers are easier to handle when you cut the cord, and the Bosch’s compact, curvy shape and unique base give it unmatched control.

Buy at Amazon