Anyone have an optionion about routers?
Which Router should I buy, the Bosch 1617EVS or the PC 690 series?
I will buy the kit with both the fixed and plunge bases and plan to use it for everything from making raised panels when mounted under the table to rounding edges.
I have been attracted to the Bosch for a while, but PC’s above the table height adjustment seems sweet. Also, I think the Bosch requires two wrenches to change bits. Not a huge deal, but inconvenient.
Bosch: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00005RHPD/qid=1089770867/br=1-1/ref=br_lf_hi_1//002-0794481-7916005?v=glance&s=hi&n=228262
PC: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B0000DCBKN/002-0794481-7916005?v=glance&me=ATVPDKIKX0DER&st=hi
Fine Woodworking Recommended Products
DeWalt DWE6423 5-in. Random Orbit Sander
- Stock removal was poor - Dust collection was near the bottom without a vacuum, but very solid with one - Roomy waist leaves plenty of options for gripping
Shop Fox W1844
Although seemingly identical to the Grizzly G0785, the Shop Fox W1844 delivered slightly better suction than the Grizzly. Bag changes are easy on both machines, thanks to a nice-fitting bag that stays in place while you operate the band clamp. And both units hang solidly on their brackets.
Festool Model KS 120 REB Miter Saw
Sliding compound miter saws have become a woodshop staple. Their ability to squarely crosscut wide boards and to cut difficult miter and bevel angles is huge. Festool’s Kapex KS 120 REB fulfills these duties with aplomb. The design keeps the saw close to the wall, allowing for a small footprint. The cut is rigid and precise provided you use good technique. It accepts 20mm blades, about 10 1⁄4 in. Its maximum width of cut is 12 in..
Metabo HPT C12RSH2 Miter Saw
This saw has a similar design to the best overall Makita, but it falls short because of small details that add up. First and foremost are the poor ergonomics. I find vertical handles cumbersome. The bevel lock was frustrating too. The tilt lever was at the back of the saw, meaning the tool can’t sit tight to the wall. There are no bevel detents. It’s the only saw without a flip stop, meaning you have to reset it between cuts. Still, the saw has a compact design, and it’s the most affordable of the bunch. The side extension arms have slick levelers, too.
Craftsman CMEW213 Belt Sander
Weight: 6.6 lb. Amps: 7 Variable speed: No Belt alignment: Poor Material removal rate: Poor Sanding flatness: Poor Shaping/scribing: Poor Handling on side: Excellent Dust collection with hose: N/A
Replies
I have five P-C routers in the shop, and NEVER had a problem or break down. So, from a durability standpoint, they are hard to beat.
I am developing a Bosch bias. I think their stuff, in general, is great. I have one of their routers for 3 years . I have three Bosch portable power tools, and will consider them first when I make my next purchase
Hans
You can't go wrong with either of your choices. Both are outstanding in their own ways. As you mentioned, one has options that the other doesn't, and so on. You'll need to thoroughly evaluate your router needs now and then think about how the features of each router may effect your ability to perform functions that may be required in the future.
Try to remember that every product sold has a certain amount of psychological hype built into its features. In other words, don't get hung up on features that you will probably never use.
Personally, I would lean towards the Porter Cable simply because of their wide selection and dedication to the line over the years. In my opinion, their level of quality has never wavered and they are not one to jump on the bandwagon and slap a bunch of unnecessary wing dings on their products. If something makes sense, they do it, otherwise, they let the others be the ones who are constantly re-tooling in an attempt to keep up with their sales.
From a sales perspective, Porter Cable is easily 10 to 1 over their closest competition, which by the way, in my store is Bosch.
Sincerely;
The Tool Guy
I have 3 PC and 2 Bosch. They work the same but the Bosches are noisier.
They are both great routers, I have both a porter cable 690 and a bosch 2 1/4 hp plunge router. The first thing I should mention is that neither is suitable for raising panels, you need something bigger, or if you do enough, get a shaper.
My advice is go to the store, pick them both up, look at them feature for feature, if possible try them both out and then make a decision.
Andrew
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled