Skip to content
Fine Woodworking
Main Menu
Subscribe
GET THE MAGAZINE & MORE
Magazine Cover
  • Save 69% off the cover price
  • Or, get everything with UNLIMITED, including 40+ years of the online archive.
Subscribe Now!
Subscribe
  • Projects & Plans
  • How-To
  • Shop Tips
  • Tools & Materials
  • Videos
  • Magazine
  • Video Workshops
  • Members
  • Forum
  • Gallery
  • Blogs
  • More
    • Log In
    • Join
    Fine Woodworking Main Menu Subscribe
    Shop Talk Live

    STL235: Are saw guides really cheating?

    Vic Tesolin joins Mike and Ben to discuss jack planes, smoothing planes, shop lighting, and if saw guides are cheating or not.

    Feb 26, 2021

    Question 1: 

    From Bob:
    I have another question about planes.  I hear you talk about jack and smoothing planes.  You also talk about #4 and #5 planes.  Sometimes you will talk about a #4 smoother or a #4 jack.  Can you explain the difference between a smoothing plane and a jack plane?  Does it have something to do with the way it is sharpened or the way it is set up?  Enquiring mind would like to know.

    Make a wooden pull plane

    Vic Tesolin’s wooden pull plane is not a Japanese plane, but his own version that cuts on the pull stroke instead of pushing like a standard western plane.



    Question 2:

    From Matthew:
    I am in the process of finishing my shop and I need to figure out how to best create natural light during the short winter days. The space is roughly 20×15 with 10′ ceilings and two main working areas. During the day, windows allow for plenty of natural light comfortable for working. Currently I am using basic utility lights with “daylight” bulbs as a way of getting started. I quickly realized multiple light sources cast unwanted shadows making marks difficult to see.

    My question is: What are the best types of overhead lighting that can give a similar feel as natural daylight and also an even light? I am curious about not only bulb temp but also style of fixture such as tracks with multiple heads, fluorescent, or something that is more direct and moveable like an articulating desk lamp.

    ‘The Centre for Woodworking Authenticity’

    In the end, any woodworking you enjoy is authentic woodworking.

    Mike recommends following and supporting @woodschrew on Instagram.

    Ben recommends grinding down a washer to tighten down your Lie Nielsen honing guide.


    Every two weeks, a team of Fine Woodworking staffers answers questions from readers on Shop Talk Live, Fine Woodworking‘s biweekly podcast. Send your woodworking questions to [email protected] for consideration in the regular broadcast! Our continued existence relies upon listener support. So if you enjoy the show, be sure to leave us a five-star rating and maybe even a nice comment on our iTunes page.

    Sign up for eletters today and get the latest techniques and how-to from Fine Woodworking, plus special offers.

    Sign Up

    Get woodworking tips, expert advice and special offers in your inbox

    Sign Up
    ×
    X
    X

    New Feature

    Fine Woodworking Forums

    Ask questions, offer advice, and share your work

    Get It All!

    UNLIMITED Membership is like taking a master class in woodworking for less than $10 a month.

    Start Your Free Trial

    Subscribe to Fine Woodworking

    Save up to 56%

    Subscribe

    Comments

    1. User avater
      TaunTonMacoute | Feb 26, 2021 12:00pm | #1

      One needs as few gewgaws, bits, bobs, and duplicates in the shop as possible.

    2. Kevin_Almeyda | Feb 26, 2021 04:21pm | #2

      This was a fantastic episode. Thank you Vic for defending the dovetail guide!

      A dovetail guide. A simple tool that allows me to cut dovetails faster and better. True, if I’m ever on a desert island with only a saw and there’s a dovetail competition I’m f***** but I’m going to risk it. #hero.

    3. sawinglogs | Feb 26, 2021 06:24pm | #3

      Loved this episode. Just bought Vic's book and a dovetail saw guide. Threw in the Fine Woodwrking book on hand tools for good measure. Now I have to find Mike's router bit. Great conversation and truly inspirational.

    4. woodnslatestudio | Feb 27, 2021 09:41am | #4

      good job guys cudos to Vic never stop trying, learning, improving, or enjoying

    5. User avater
      Lat_axe | Feb 27, 2021 02:35pm | #5

      Jigs & aids to guide the tool .....

      Is there a tool that doesn't incorporate a jig? A knife edge needs the knife body to support it and a handle to operate it. Even a rock to hit a post is better if it's a human hand size and shape rather than one suiting an elephant's trunk, eh? Did Big Uggy sneer at Little Grunt because Grunt preferred his rocks to be this size and shape rather than that? Probably.

      Just because a jig isn't intimately connected to the tool using it doesn't mean the jig is "cheating" or inessential. (Cheating who; or which rule-set)? Try using a table saw without a fence. I've seen it done but fainted because of the worry the lad was going to come to a bad end.

      ****
      Perhaps there could be a FWW contest in which readers send in pics or vids of themselves using completely unjigged tools? How long does it take to plane a table top flat using just the plane blade but no plane, for example? I believe there is a Japanese chisel-thing that is used in this fashion, mind. It has a handle though - is that cheating? Perhaps Vic will be making one so we can see?

      Lataxe

    6. User avater
      MMehalic | Feb 28, 2021 08:41am | #6

      I purchased one of the LED headlamps the guys mentioned to use as task light when cutting dovetails and it made a world of difference.

    7. User avater
      Freddy228 | Feb 28, 2021 08:19pm | #7

      Fantastic episode. I would have happily listened to the raw 90 minutes of this podcast.

    8. User avater
      Freddy228 | Feb 28, 2021 08:22pm | #8

      Hey Ben, can you please post the link where Vic mentions he watched or read an article how Mike uses the trim router for dovetails?

      1. User avater FWW Editor
        BenStrano | Mar 01, 2021 09:17am | #9

        It's shown in detail here:
        https://www.finewoodworking.com/2020/03/26/all-in-one-workstation-for-dovetails
        And here:
        https://www.finewoodworking.com/2020/01/07/ep-5-fitting-the-dovetails

        1. Kevin_Almeyda | Mar 01, 2021 10:31pm | #11

          Thanks for posting this, Ben. I was wondering how Mike balanced the router on the pins. This cleared it up.

        2. User avater
          wbfinewoodworking | Mar 07, 2021 07:49pm | #13

          Thanks for the links Ben. You saved me a lot of searching. Now I have a good reason to buy a small router. Is there a link somewhere to the bit that mike used?

          You three make a great combination for the podcast. For some reason the chemistry between this trio creates a lot of very helpful information. I’d like to see Vic join you more often.

          BTW — The dovetail jigs came Friday from Tailspin Tools. They also threw in Tailspin SQd as a bonus. I’m looking forward to trying both out sometime this year when I have a project that requires dovetails. Thanks for setting up the possibility for me to win them.

    9. user-7214132 | Mar 01, 2021 12:19pm | #10

      Yea, a plane is a jig for a chisel, and a table saw a jig for a handsaw, but personally, when I see these guys with a backdrop wall of systainers,,,

      Where is the line? It is a personal decision and does not itself matter in the quality of work. Machined wood is how production furniture and quality woodworking tools are made.

      I think, Ben said it best, nobody says, Oh boy, now I get to use my screaming router!

    10. glennaz | Mar 03, 2021 07:24pm | #12

      I adopted Mike P.'s method of routing the pin waste with the short flush trim bit, but with one adaptation. He demonstrates it with a hand held trim router on a clever bench on bench clamping platform thing.

      I found it much simpler (and faster) to just clamp the workpiece to a simple right angle backer and use the flush trim bit in the router table.
      I made a clearance rabbet at the bottom of the backer to create some space for the bearing to pass all the way through the pin board.
      As an added bonus, I have much better dust control at the router table.

      This system has probably cut down my hand dovetailing time by 50%. Thanks Mike!

    11. User avater
      Ed_Pirnik | Mar 11, 2021 03:00pm | #14

      For shame! One less doo-dad I need collecting dust in my shop. Miss you guys:)

    Log in or create an account to post a comment.

    Sign up Log in

    More Shop Talk Live

    View All
    • STL238: Tim Coleman's shopsawn veneer secrets–revealed!

    • STL237: Just the facets, ma'am

    • STL236: Does a jointer save you money?

    • STL234: When animation inspires your furniture designs

    View All

    Up Next

    Featured Workshop

    a diagram of a round Shaker stand and an image or a round Shaker stand

    Shaker candle stand with Christian Beckvoort

    He’s built dozens of round Shaker stands over four decades, so there is no one more qualified than Christian Becksvoort to demonstrate making this classic. In this seven-part video series,…

    Featured Projects & Plans

    Build a Contemporary Sideboard

    Chris Gochnour's sideboard combines usefulness, strength, and beauty in a contemporary case piece

    Related Stories

    • Workshop Tip: Repair a bowl without taking it off the lathe

    • Milling parts for perfect drawers

    • Webinar: Systematic handplaning with Bob Van Dyke

    • Custom toolbars in SketchUp

    Discussion Forum

    Recent Posts and Replies

    • |
    • |
    • |
    • |
    • |
    • |
    View More Create Post

    Member Exclusives

    More Member Exclusives
    • How to Make a Tabletop Float

      Simple and sturdy joinery allows the top of David Welter's table to float without overshadowing the rest of the design or blocking the flow of light between base and top.

    • tune up block plane

      How to tune up your block plane

      Whether your block plane is new or vintage, follow these steps to get it running at full capacity.

    • Simple dovetailed Box

      Milling Stock for a Dovetailed Box

      How to mill parts for a box that are straight, flat, and square.

    • wiping varnish finish

      How to brush on a varnish finish

      A wiping varnish goes on easily and creates a tough surface ready for rubbing out.

    Highlights

    • Shape Your Skills

      when you sign up for our emails

      Plus tips, advice, and special offers from Fine Woodworking.

      Sign Up
    • Shop Talk Live Podcast

      Shop Talk Live Podcast

      Our biweekly podcast allows editors, authors, and special guests to answer your woodworking questions and connect with the online woodworking community.

    • Woodpecker Sweepstakes

      Woodpeckers Shop Upgrade Giveaway

      Enter now for your chance to win more than $2,000 worth of woodworking equipment from Woodpeckers. Click for full details.

    • Staff Picks Blog

      Our favorite articles and videos

      We have created these special content collections organized to give you a deep dive into a range of topics that matter.

    From the Store

    View More
    • Complete Illustrated Guide to Woodworking USB

      Buy Now
    • 2020 Fine Woodworking Archive

      Buy Now
    • 52 Boxes in 52 Weeks

      Buy Now
    • The Why & How of Woodworking

      Buy Now
    View More

    Get the latest from Fine Woodworking Magazine

    • #289-May/June 2021

      • Arts and Crafts coffee table with story-book charm
      • Links from Fine Woodworking issue #289
      • Seven tasks for a block plane
    • #288-Mar/Apr 2021

      • Phil Lowe: A craftsman and gentleman
      • Online Extras from FWW Issue #288
      • Phil Lowe: craftsman, teacher, friend
    • #287-Jan/Feb 2021

      • Simple, handsome 17th-century box
      • Online extras from FWW issue #287
      • Editor's letter: Finding sanctuary in the shop
    • #286-Tools & Shops 2021

      • Shoulder plane setup and use
      • Online extras from FWW issue #286
      • From the editor: A shop to call home
    • #285-Nov/Dec 2020

      • Make a dovetailed desktop organizer
      • Online Extras from FWW Issue #285
      • Announcing FWW ambassadors

    UNLIMITED membership - Get access to it all

    Start Free Trial Upgrade Membership

    Fine WoodWorking

    Follow

    Newsletter

    Get woodworking tips, expert advice and special offers in your inbox

    Sign Up

    Membership & Magazine

    • Members
    • Digital Libraries
    • Join Unlimited
    • Magazine Subscription
    • Magazine Renewal
    • Gift a Subscription
    • Customer Support
    • Manage Preferences

    Taunton Network

    • Fine Homebuilding
    • Green Building Advisor
    • Fine Gardening
    • Threads
    • About
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Policy
    • Careers
    • Copyright
    • Terms of Use
    • Accessibility
    • California Privacy Rights

    © 2021 The Taunton Press, Inc. All rights reserved.

    Get instant access to over 100 digital plans available only to UNLIMITED members. Start your 14-day FREE trial - and get building!

      Main Menu

    • Projects and Plans
    • How-To
    • Shop Tips
    • Tools & Materials
    • Videos
    • Gallery
    • Magazine
    • Video Workshops
    • Members
    • Forum

      Popular Topics

    • Design
    • Small Projects
    • Beds
    • Chairs, Benches And Stools
    • Built-ins
    • Storage And Shelves
    • Cabinets
    • Carving
    • Casework
    • Desks
    • Tables
    • Shop Storage And Furniture
    • Woodturning Projects
    • Workbenches
    • Surface Prep

      More

    • TV
    • Forum
    • Blogs
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Customer Support

      Account

    • Log In
    • Join

      Magazine

    • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
    • Digital Libraries
    • Magazine Index
    • Subscribe

      Membership

    • Member Home
    • Start Free Trial
    • Gift Unlimited
    • Log In

      Shop the Store

    • Books
    • DVDs
    • Taunton Workshops

      Events

    • Fine Woodworking Live
    • Fine Woodworking HANDS ON

      Account

    • Log In
    • Sign Up

    Newsletter

    Get woodworking tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

    Sign Up

    Follow

    UNLIMITED

    Become an UNLIMITED member and get it all: searchable online archive of every issue, how-to videos, Complete Illustrated Guide to Woodworking digital series, print magazine, e-newsletter, and more.

    Start Your Free Trial

    Upgrade Membership