Power Boat Reports just did a review of anti corrosion sprays. PBR is a periodical that does reviews of equipment and products related to boating and does not take advertisements. Corrosion of steel is as much, or more, of an issue with boaters as it is with cast iron tool tops. Their review covered 12 products listed below.
Briefly, they took two steel coupons for each product and sprayed each with the given product. Then they sprayed each with fresh water or salt water. Waited awhile and recorded the results. They picked a “Budget Buy”, CRC Heavy Duty “Recommended”, LPS 3 and “Best Choice” Corrosionpro Lube.
Test Products
Boeshield T-9
Corrosion Block
Corrosionpro Lube
Corrosionx and HD
CRC HD
LPS 1, and 2, and 3
Shark Hide
TC-11
WD-40
Interestingly, the two products in my shop, WD-40 and Boeshield did not fair well. This is a reader supported periodical so the website is not open, but the link is …
http://www.powerboat-reports.com/issues/20_4/features/5781-1.html
Replies
Everybody has a gimmick.
Though corrosion is a problem with tools, the easiest and least expensive remedy is wax. I use carnuba, some use furniture paste. I can go over a year before having to rewax my TS. Most of the time I'm waxing to reduce friction and so I never have an issue with TS rust. I wax other tools as well and it works pretty good there too.
I waxed my table saw and jointer when I bought both new within a month of each other. I waxed them at least once a week after that and they both rusted lightly. They were kept in a shop that was only heated with portable heaters when I was working so they were subject to a considerable amount of moisture.
After having my fill of that routine I bought a can of CRC Table Gaurd. I applied it after scrubbing and sanding all of the rust off of both. I reapplied about 3 months later and then got lazy and didn't reapply for over a year. Absolutely no rust on anything I used it on for the year and a half they were in the sometimes heated shop. Now they are in a heated shop so the rust issue is much less but I still use it for the friction reduction. It lasts a lot longer than wax and is easier to apply. I have used maybe half a $7 dollar can in over 2 years. Spray on, wipe off, that's it.
Rob
"If it ain't broke, don't fix it"
Sounds like your in good shape there. Carnuba works for me, I guess it all depends on shop humidity conditions.
Ron
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled