I’m working on a white oak L shaped computer desk. One corner piece, one extension table on the left. The surface is solid oak. I’ll build some drawers and put them on casters so they can slide under the desk, and be pulled out if I need more workspace. I’m planning to paint the drawers black, since there is so much wood already visible. I’ve heard of milk paint, but never seen it. Is it reasonable to make the drawers out of poplar and paint them black with milk paint? I think what I’m asking is does milk paint look like paint or more like stain, and is poplar an appropriate material for this?
Fine Woodworking Recommended Products
Bessey K-Body Parallel-Jaw Clamp
The 3 3/4" deep parallel jaws allow for all types of clamping, from thin panels to joinery.
Mirka Direct Electric Random Orbital Sander 5-in.
- Excellent dust collection and stock removal. Must be used with a vacuum - The paddle switch was awkward to use, but the shape of the head made handling - Comfortable with one hand or two - Stops very quickly.
Rikon 10-3061 10-in. Deluxe Bandsaw
The 1⁄2-hp motor has all the power needed to resaw at its maximum capacity of 5 in.
The saw has two speeds: 3,280 sfpm (surface feet per minute) for wood and 1,515 sfpm for soft metals and some plastics.
Triton TPT125 Planer
Accessing the knives on the Triton for changes was not difficult, but getting the knives out was tricky, because no magnetized handles were provided to lift the knives off the cutterhead. There is a 2-1/2-in.-dia. dust port, and chip collection was good when hooked up to a shop vacuum. The housing has an open top and just one return roller on top, making it impossible to stack boards there in between passes through the machine. Also, there is no gauge that indicates how much material you are removing in a pass, making it one of four planers that don’t offer this feature.
Circle Guide
If you like to draw your designs on paper, you'll find the simple circle guide to be very helpful.
Replies
You can mix the milk paint powder with enough water that it would look like a wash or stain, but it's not necessary. By itself it is essentially a flat finish, and often a little grainy. But it can be lightly sanded and topped with a coat of an oil/varnish mix that will intensify the color and provide a hint of sheen. For more sheen you would have to use a wiping varnish over the milk paint. But, if you want to do that, you might as well just use a black enamel. Check out the websites for the manufacturers. Twocommon ones are Old Fashioned Milk Paint at http://www.milkpaint.com and Real Milk Paint at http://www.realmilkpaint.com
Actual milk paint comes only in powder form. If it is a liquid in a can, its not actually milk paint but an acyrlic or latex paint with milk paint colors. It's sometimes hard to tell that when you read the labels.
Very reasonable. Poplar paints well as you know. And its grain is tight. But the milk paint will never really fill the grain. So its not like a stain in that the color will be opaque. But it is like a stain in that the texture of the wood will be apparent. With black, I'm not sure if there are loads of advantages to using milk paint over rustoleum for example. I think the biggest advantage may be that the milk paint is water based and dries fast so workshop dust isn't a problem, clean up isn't a problem etc.
With other colors, I think the pigment looks different. The pigment itself is not as finely ground as commercial paints. So green milk paint really looks different than green latex for example.
Adam
You're talking about the drawer cabinet and/or the drawer fronts, right? As a finish, milk paint would certainly be suitable. It's very opaque, easy to apply, and wears well. However, I suspect that the look isn't what you'd really want for a computer desk. It has a rather dull matte finish, and the brush strokes tend to be visible. A sprayed lacquer finish is probably more in tune with electronic hardware.
Poplar is fine for the interior parts (drawer sides and backs), but is really too soft for the exposed cabinet and drawer fronts. It will likely receive lots of dents and dings that will go through the finish and expose the light color of the wood. I would use soft maple instead. (Hard maple or birch would be even better, but they are usually significantly more expensive.) I would also first dye it black (to reduce the likelihood of a ding exposing the white wood) and then overcoat the dye with paint/lacquer. It might be a good idea to include a sealer coat of shellac between the dye and the topcoats, too.
-Steve
I just assumed it was a Shaker reproduction computer desk.
My memory must be failing me (old age), as I can't even remember whether the Shakers favored Macs or PCs.
-Steve
Everyone has given you good descriptions of milk paint. It will wear like iron. I don't think it could be chipped if you wanted to!! It is also a bit of a rough feeling paint, and benefits from a topcoat of a clear coat so you can wipe things up/off of it. Also, you will never be able to totally get rid of the color should you ever want to strip and make it natural wood. Might not be likely, but just an "in case".
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled