I am in the midst of a set of 10 dining room chairs. The design calls for a lot of mortises and I am considering buying a benchtop hollow chisel mortiser. I *think* I have narrowed my choices to the Steel City mortiser or the Powermatic. Does anyone have one of these and do you like it (or another machine like over either of these)?
thanks
Jeff
Replies
I had the Powermatic benchtop 701 (until I got a deal on their floor model) and liked it a bunch. Very well built, lots of nice features. I have a review of it at the link below with photos and video that might help on this model.
http://www.newwoodworker.com/reviews/pm701rvu.html
Tom Hintz
Because there is always more to learn!
When I saw the PM 701 just before Christmas, I thought "Well! Looks alot like my Steel City!" which I bought 2+ years ago. Checking out Tom's review, I'd say the took the SC design and upped the ante a bit with the tooless approach and slightly bigger motor. The Steel City is a nice mortiser, the warantee is unmatched, and the extra stock support built into the table is a plus, but the extra features on the Powermatic might be worth the extra money.
I bought the Powermatic last spring when it was on sale at Woodcraft. Been very satisfied with it and it sure makes life easier--and the work more accurate--than doing the mortises with my router. There was a brief review in a Popular Woodworking issue that was enthusiastic about the Powermatic. The other bench top mortiser I considered was the General, which has a tilting head (might be useful for chair work) but I didn't get a chance to see it and couldn't find significant reviews, so I went with the Powermatic. Haven't seen any users dissatisfied with the Powermatic so that's probably a good indication.
I did have one minor issue with my 701 Powermatic, but an e-mail to tech support brought an immediate response that solved the problem. I couldn't be happier--unless someone would gift me with the floor model Tom mentioned.
Bob
I have the PM 719 and although I haven't used it much at all, it certainly seems like a substantial machine. It has the traveling carriages and the stops. The carriages could work more easily but it is not bad. I got it when you had the choice of getting the supporting bench and chose to save my shekels. I have a whole bunch of bed frames and made the base.
I have the general, seams nice, but I have not used it much. (I had to buy the tools a few years ago to replace what I had, due to insurance issues) At the time i picked it up it seamed like the best available, but that was befor SC came out (alas SC came out with thier line about 4 months to late for me or I would have SC everything sigh...)
Doug
I bought the General based on the fact that it would be easier to do angled mortises(chair making). I do however like the Powermatic rack and pinion fence.
Mike
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled