I searched the archives and was amazed not to find more info on stile and rail bits.
Specifically what I wanted to know is which type is best: Stacked, reversible, or separate bits?
I only have one router table so it seems like reversible would be the easiest to switch out and, I assume, retain proper depth settings. Although, it seems to me they may wear out quickly as they are used twice as much.
Stacked bits seem a good option but still would require resetting the depth each time. It also seems that the extra length of the bit may cause a flex/strain/vibration problem.
I am guessing separate bits would be nice only if I had another router table.
What do you all think is the best set up on a single router table?
thanks
gk
Edited 4/14/2008 11:17 am ET by Dreamcatcher
Replies
Dreamcatcher,
My recommendation would be separate, 1/2 shank, of good quality carbide bits, from a reputable manufacturer.
Any vibration or flexing from a 1/4 shaft is going to show up in the fit of the joint. Same goes for poorly crafted bits, so this isn't the place to save a few bucks, in my opinion.
As for the reversables... figure out what your time is worth.. when you're on your hands and knees swearing, looking for that little shim that fell through the dog hole in your bench and is in that pile of sawdust somewhere. And wait, does this go upside down or rightside up when it goes back together for the cope? How many shims go here?
Frankfive,Thanks, I guess I didn't mention the shank diameter because in my mind it just goes without saying that 1/2" shank is the only way to go on most bits.Do you run two router tables for using two bits? That would seem optimal to run tests to get perfect setups, but then I would need to build another table. gk
Dreamcatcher,
I only use one router table. I set up with the cope cutter first and do all the ends of the rails. Then I put in the stick cutter, set it to the cope cut, test it on scrap, then run all the stick cuts on the stiles and rails.
I have a router table that allows for bit changing and router height adjustment easilly without removing anything from the table or going through contortions.
Frank
I prefer the reversible kind, but I can't seem to find them lately. On the set I have, I never needed shims, so losing them was never a factor. I find it far easier to remove the nut from the top and re-stack them than I do to change the entire bit. On my old router, changing the bit meant removing the router, or getting under the table. With my new one, it means cranking the router all the way up until the collet is exposed. Either way, just removing the nut and restacking is a lot easier for me.
If you have a source for high quality reversible stile and rail sets, please post it up.
I was looking to buy from the PriceCutter/Eagle catalog. A friend of mine bought some bits from them and ran then on an ash project he is doing. Ran alot of stuff too. We were both amazed at how clean they were cutting and for how long they lasted. They have a great selection too and all the prices seem much lower than CMT,Freud,Amana.I figured for the price, I would try out their stile and rail cutter. If that is good I think I can trust anything they sell. Then I need to plan ahead so I don't buy everything at once. Maybe I should start the "Router Bit of the Month Club". Wanna join?gk
Go for the matched two piece sets, Thats the best way to go. Work Safe, Count to 10 when your done for the day !!
Bruce S.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled