I would just like to get some opinions from some knowlegable finishers on his new book before purchasing. I did a search here and didn’t find a prior thread. Also, i don’t trust the reviews over at amazon.
Specifically, I’m looking to build my skill in working with lacquer, dyes and toning, to create a deep luster with a rubbed out satin finish
thanks
dp
Edited 1/1/2006 7:33 pm ET by dperfe
Replies
Jeff is an accomplished finisher and a good writer. He's written more than one book on the subject; I have his "Finishing", which is one of a Taunton's "Complete Illustrated Guide" books of recent vintage. It is a nice reference and covers finshing extensively, although not at great depth (such a book would be a couple volumes). The subjects you are interested are included in the book.
See if your public library has the book. I preview most books by checking them out first from our library system.
I have Jewitt's book and agree with the other responders. Although it is almost 300 pages, it is still mostly descriptive, general, and lacks specifics. For example, when I wanted to know why aniline dye stains didn't enhance the figure in bird's-eye maple, the only mention is in a figure caption on the page before the discussion of aniline dyes begins. To be fair, such specifics would require more volumes, as the other responder said.
I also have Flexner's book, Understanding Wood Finishing, where p. 283 tells the reader to use dye stain on bird's-eye maple. What he doesn't say is that it doesn't enhance the figure more than unstained oil/varnish finish. It just changes the overall color in tone and darkness.
In a nutshell, these books are a good beginning. But in finishing, a lot depends on the character of the wood in hand. So no book can replace systematic experimentation on sample pieces.
Edited 1/6/2006 10:21 am by JohnH
By the way, Flexner has changed the treatment in the current revised edition. He uses the dye in a very diluted fashion and suggests sanding or scraping off the color between the curls or bird's eyes between each application of dye. He then intensifies the impact with a coat of BLO after the dye has dried. (p. 237)
Hi Steve,
Thanks for the update on Jewitt's newest edition. Call me lazy, I think that I'll be happy with the figure resulting from a good oil/varnish finish.
Best regards, John
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled