Has anyone actually compared samples of finishes to see if the oil makes a darn bit of difference. I just did one half a cherry board with Moser Polymerized Tung Oil (3 coats) and the other without, covered them both with 6 coats of garnet shellac and a couple coats of wax. Not even my instructor could tell the difference. After seeing the lack of difference with my own eyes, Im wondering if the popping characteristics of oil are overratted or if some historian made the assumption that was the reason oil was used.
Fine Woodworking Recommended Products
JessEm Wood Sabre
The beam has deep detents that index the fence precisely at 1/2-in. increments, and there’s a well-machined and easy-to-read micrometer adjustment that will set the gauge to any distance between the indexed points. However, the detents are so positive that they sometimes interfere, drawing the fence toward them.
Leigh D4R Pro
The D4R Pro is Leigh’s flagship jig. Like the other Leigh jigs in our test, it represents a different world of quality, from its clear, comprehensive instructions to its ingenious engineering, impeccable manufacturing, and unmatched capabilities.
Dividers
Incredibly useful for laying out, setting equal distances, and comparing measurements, these are an essential tool for any furniture maker.
Ridgid R86044B
Power: Good Cut visibility: Very good Control: Good (with standard base) Bit changes: Good Depth adjustment: Excellent
40 Pcs Wooden Bead Kit
Package includes: 6/8/10/12/14/15/16/18/20/22/25mm blade+1pcs shank+ 26pcs cores.
Replies
Yes, oil is overrated for popping the grain. That's what your test validated, didn't it? :)
Edited 4/13/2006 10:57 pm ET by Spike2
Opinion wise, i think what the oil is under and on what wood makes some difference. My own very unscientific testing has me believing that oil before lacquer (with plenty of cure time inbetween) makes a dramatic difference on cherry vs just lacquer. Can't say I've tried it with shellac. Maybe I'll do that and get back to you in about, oh, 3 years sound good? :-)
"Sometimes when I consider what tremendous consequences come from little things, I am tempted to think -- there are no little things" - Bruce Barton
I suspect there would be more difference with Super Blonde shellac instead of garnet, and of course in the reductio ad absurdum, a clear water borne finish, with and without the oil. But I don't see much difference between oil and an amber varnish, and the amber varnish by itself.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled