Replies

1. 
   peter28 | Jan 26, 2009 04:47pm | #1

   root,

   I don't think the weathered surface really needs a finish. If it were mine I would make those new surfaces match the old one.

   To see what the difference in color will be between the old and the new surface wipe the planed surface with alcohol. You can also use naptha or mineral spirits but the alcohol will evaporate a lot quicker with less odor.

   As far as a finish goes; if you used a wiping varnish such as watco , minwax antique oil etc. it will have a darkening effect on the new surfaces. If that is what you're looking for it's quite simple to do. If you use an oil, be sure and lay those oily rags flat outside to dry before throwing them away.

   Or you could use shellac. Applying a shellac like SealCoat will minimize the darkening. You wouldn't need much either; two or three applications on the new surfaces would suffice. You could then rub it back with a maroon scotch pad for a dull look or a grey pad and a little wax for a soft shine.

   Whatever you chose, less is definately more in this instance. You really don't need to build a significant finish on the mantle. If it was a formal mahogany mantle that would be a different story.

   Make some samples with your cutoffs. This will tell you all you need to know visually.

   Good luck.

   Peter 

    

    

    

1. 
   root | Jan 26, 2009 07:46pm | #2

   Thank you, Peter.  This is pretty much what I was thinking, but it is nice to have an expert opinion to back-up my thought process.  Have a great day!