Sheeesh…I think I’m ready to give up on dovetail router jigs. Yesterday, I spent the better part of three hours setting up a name-brand dovetail jig. Once I had it set up, it did an OK job, but there was more tear out than I thought was acceptable (yes..I used a backing board.)
Out of frustration, I did the unthinkable…I picked up my dovetail saw *gasp*. I have toyed around with cutting dovetails by hand before, but this time I took my time and was diligent in my marking and cutting.
Ya know what? It didn’t suck! AND…I put together a simple frame in about 2 hours! Now, I know I’m not ready for prime-time, but with a little practice?? Hmmm…..
Cliff
Replies
And I bet the air was as clean when done as when you started. You are right Cliff that jigs may be good for runs but one offs or specials done by hand with care promote a sense of achievement.
Steeper (than one might think) learning curve with those things.
Mr Crowe,
I agree - those jigs and other mechanised helpers have to be larnt and the necessary skills acquired, just as with hand tools but the skills are different ones. Personally I like to get all the skills I can so don't mind larnin' jigs as well as saws and planes. It's all wood-grist to the furniture-mill. Variety is the spice of shed-life.
Now I am able to make a very nice DT or finger joint in many ways; many, many ways. I have got beyond breakout, wonky cuts and ill-fits, so I am a happy man and all the swearing and pouting at dang tools is behind me (until the next new toy must be mastered, that is).
Lataxe, playboy of the Galgate shed.
Cliff,
I could not agree with you more! I even upgraded a couple years ago to that very popular jig with variable spacing, etc. And I have to get the book out every time I want to use it. If the results were great, maybe it would be worth it; but the results are just good.
I've just committed to hand cut dovetails... so much, in fact, that last week I enrolled in a 2-day class in Philadelphia taught by Mario Rodriguez. I've never formally learned the process and have only had mediocre results. And you're never too old to learn to do something the right way!
I'm glad your post went where it did. The title left a lot to the imagination.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled