The Woodworking Life

The Woodworking Life

Fixing my miscut, dovetailed rail

comments (7) January 3rd, 2012 in blogs

kenstonge Ken St. Onge, Associate Editor
thumbs up 13 users recommend

I split the side of the leg and miscut this dovetail. I needed to correct it.
The dovetail holds the top rail in place. Its unseen, but is an important part of the joinery for the base.
I chopped the wedges with a chisel and then used a marking knife to cut them to size.
After the glue dried, I used a block plane to flatten the surface. Its a big improvement.
I split the side of the leg and miscut this dovetail. I needed to correct it. - CLICK TO ENLARGE

I split the side of the leg and miscut this dovetail. I needed to correct it.


Dovetails are used all over the place in woodworking, but for newbies like me, they're intimidating to cut. Perhaps the biggest reason is that any mistakes are so easily visible. When dovetails are miscut, it's obvious. Learning to cut dovetails, for me at least, means learning to fix my mistakes. Like the one I just made.

It happened last week while I was working on a lunch time project here at FWW. I'm building the tapered leg Shaker side table from Christian Becksvoort's article in FWW 210. The plans call for a dovetailed top rail on the front of the nightstand. I had already cut the tails when I decided to try cutting the socket entirely by hand, rather than with a router, which Becksvoort advises.

In hindsight, I should have used clamps to bolster the sides of the legs. After a few quick taps with a chisel, the leg started to split. I panicked, grabbed the router and began cleaning up the rest of the socket with it. In all the confusion, I ended up overcutting the socket, which left sizable gaps on either side of the tail.

I glued up the base, left for the long weekend, and decided to come back in today and fix my very obvious error. Since the rail will be concealed by the table top, I wasn't worried about the aesthetics of my ugly joint. But I did want the rail to be secure, especially since I had made a hairline split in the front of the leg.

I decided to try fixing it using wedges cut from the end grain of the same boards, a technique that Phil Lowe covered back in FWW 186. I used a chisel to cut the wedges and then glued them in place. Thankfully, I had left the dovetails a little proud, so after the wedges dried, I used a block plane to flatten the surface and bring the rail flush with the top of the legs. It's not as pretty as I would like, but it should be strong enough to hold the base together without any problems.



posted in: blogs, how to, table, dovetails, cherry, shaker


Comments (7)

BluhminOnion BluhminOnion writes: Just read the FWW reference article - thanks for that, and I think the repair looks great.
Posted: 3:36 pm on January 11th

Mattk41 Mattk41 writes: It just be be the photograph and the angle, but it looks to me that the top of the leg isn't square...even with the nice repair...are the reveals the same across the front of the case?
Posted: 4:42 pm on January 10th

Aledrinker Aledrinker writes: Nice fix. I recently split an end table leg at that same spot myself while chopping out the socket. Although I have high regard for Christian Becksvoort, the proportions for the dovetail here (http://www.finewoodworking.com/pages/w00078.asp) seem a bit more in "balance", looking at the different modes of possible failure of both mating pieces.
Posted: 3:58 am on January 8th

woodluc woodluc writes: Dovetail Joints are definitly not my stong point either. Good job, I'm pretty sure I will need to use this technique in the future :)
Posted: 7:56 pm on January 5th

gatordoc gatordoc writes: I think there are two issues, one aesthetic and one structural. As you point out, the aesthetic one is not important here. To maximize the structural support, I think you want the wedges to be the least wedge-like you can manage. In essence you want long straight shims so the entirety of the joint is filled, not just the top. With wedges, the top of the dovetail is fixed, but the lower part of the joint is still going to be loose. I think this is where one adds "DAMHIK".


Posted: 2:37 pm on January 4th

wdwerker wdwerker writes: all craftsmen make mistakes. Master craftsmen know how to fix them! Good repair!
Posted: 10:14 am on January 4th

MKWerman MKWerman writes: Great fix. Hope you don't give up on hand cutting out the waste. You have so much more control by hand. Just have to be careful to orient the chisel across the grain.
Posted: 9:54 pm on January 3rd

You must be logged in to post comments. Log in.

Advertise here for as little as $50. Learn how

Save up to 51% on Fine Woodworking

 

Become a Better Woodworker

ABOUT THE WOODWORKING LIFE

Get to know the woodworkers who make Fine Woodworking's online community the liveliest woodworking forum on the Web.

Each week, The Woodworking Life will feature the best projects, topical discussions, and how-to tips direct from the community.

WE WANT YOU! Find out how you can become a contributor to The Woodworking Life.

Looking for our archive?