T-Track is a Smart Workbench Accessory
Fixing Woodworking Mistakes
Tablesaw Tapering Jig is Safer and Faster
Router Jig for Perfectly Aligned Dadoes
Dedicated Sled Delivers Perfect Finger Joints
Best Tabletop Finish
How to Sharpen a Card Scraper
Five Minute Guide: How to Use a Tablesaw
How to Cut Sliding Dovetail Joints
How to Apply an Aerosol Finish
Five Minute Guide: Glue-Ups
Upgrade Your Jointer with a Segmented Cutterhead
3 Steps to Great Glue-Ups: Sliding Dovetail Joints
How to Make a Simple Jig for Offset Knife Hinges
How to Drill Windsor Chair Mortises
Buying and Using Trim Routers
Box Making Tips and Tricks

Reader's Gallery

madrone sideboard

comments (3) April 3rd, 2011 in Reader's Gallery

Joe Scannell, member

1 user recommends

Add Comment
Print

I am currently making two sets of double doors for this sideboard. When I prepped the lumber for the stiles, I realized there were several ways to use the grain. In the Sketchup drawing I have shown two different ways (pieces #2 and 5 are already committed - joinery already done). In the left hand set the grain is "pincushioned" (#1 and 3); in the right hand set, the grain is "barreled" (#4 and 6).

I clamped the pieces in place for the photograph, to try and get a visual. The general shape of the cabinet is obvious (yes, the top of the opening is an arc), and the grain is fairly easy to see in the photo. But I cannot decide whether to orient the stiles to create a "barrel" or "pincushion" grain pattern.

I realize this may not be the appropriate place for questions such as this, but I couldn't find anywhere else to post it. Does anyone out there have an opinion on my grain-orientation quandary?

Design or Plan used: My own design

posted in: Reader's Gallery, sideboard

Add Comment Print

Jewelry/Keepsake Chest

Back to List

Kumiko art - landscape

Comments (3)

Joe Scannell writes: Thank you both for your comments and advice. I guess I knew the right thing to do, but needed your push to make me do it. I have decided to 1) replace pieces #2&5 with more straight-grained material and recut the joints; and 2) realign the edges on the other pieces so the grain is "straightened" (ala James Krenov). I haven't finished, but I already feel more confident about the outcome.
Posted: 11:53 pm on April 10th

MKenney writes: Of the two choices you offer I would pick barrel, so that the grain looks like sets of parentheses. A door always looks better when the grain encircles the frame. But if I had my choice, it would all be straight grain. Of course, that might not be an option.

Good luck.
Posted: 8:36 am on April 8th

hhmacdonald writes: That's a very interesting question. The norm would be that each door would have a separate oval shaped grain pattern similar to 5 and 6. This makes each door a closed 'container'.

But you could with the use of the strong laterals of the drawers make one very large container with 1 and 2 mimicking 3 and 4 and 5 shaped like 6 in the drawing. Or (((==))).
Posted: 10:46 pm on April 3rd

You must be logged in to post comments. Log in.